The gist
- Final: ESU 17, Fort Hays State 22. The Hornets outgained the Tigers 379-289 and won the first-down battle 24-11, and still walked out of Hays with a third straight loss.
- Two explosive plays did it. A 71-yard touchdown pass on Fort Hays's second drive and a 67-yard touchdown run in the fourth quarter accounted for 138 of the Tigers' 289 yards. Take those two away and the defense held FHS to 151 yards on 51 snaps.
- Red-zone pain. ESU drove to the Fort Hays 2 on the opening series and turned it over on downs, settled for a 24-yard field goal on the next long drive, and was intercepted in the end zone with 46 seconds left on the drive that could have won it.
- 8-3 regular season, 310-267 on the year. Four Hornets landed on the All-MIAA first team on Nov. 17, with Landon Boss a unanimous pick. Sixteen selections in all. Super Region 4 selection waits.
The finish
The box score reads like a win. First downs, 24-11. Total yards, 379-289. Time of possession, 30:42 to 29:18. Punt average, 45.7 to 36.7. Fort Hays State converted three of 14 third downs and never found a third first down in the first half. Emporia State had the ball on the Fort Hays side of the field for most of a muggy Saturday in western Kansas and still lost by five.
The opening drive set the tone. Twelve plays, 73 yards, down to the Fort Hays 2 on fourth and goal, stopped. The next possession ended better. Eleven plays, 43 yards, Teaguen Collins punching in from the 1 on fourth-and-1, Brandon McCary's PAT making it 7-0. Fort Hays answered in one snap. Major Cantrell took the shotgun, went up top, and Kolton Coleman caught it in stride for a 71-yard touchdown. The Tigers missed the point after. 7-6.
McCary pushed it to 10-6 with a 24-yard field goal that capped a 10-play drive at the Fort Hays 7. Fort Hays answered in five plays and 73 yards, Mason McMinn to Keyshawn Dooley from four yards out, David Arriaga's extra point putting the Tigers up 13-10 at the half.
Then the third quarter happened. ESU got 10 snaps for 22 yards for the entire 15 minutes. The ugliest sequence started 1st-and-10 on the Hornets' own 1 after a punt pinned them. On 2nd and 10, Camden Crooks took a shotgun snap and was dragged down a yard deep in his own end zone. Safety. 15-10.
The fourth quarter followed the same script, then almost rewrote it. On first down after an ESU punt, AG Floyd broke outside left for 67 yards. Touchdown, PAT, 22-10. Emporia State finally answered: eight plays, 70 yards, Jamison Sarver on fourth-and-4 to Ty Walls from 11 yards out with a roughing-the-passer penalty piled on, McCary's PAT trimming it to 22-17. The Hornets forced a punt, got the ball back, and drove to the Fort Hays 4. On third-and-4 with 46 seconds left, Sarver's pass was picked off in the end zone by Donovan Guyton. Game.
| Stat | ESU | FHS |
|---|---|---|
| First downs | 24 | 11 |
| Total yards | 379 | 289 |
| Yards per play | 4.51 | 5.45 |
| Rushing yards | 89 | 138 |
| Passing yards | 290 | 151 |
| Third downs | 6-17 | 3-14 |
| Turnovers lost | 2 | 0 |
| Penalties-yards | 5-35 | 5-49 |
The season around it
The Northwest Missouri trip on Halloween was the kind of beating you have to flush. Three turnovers went for scores, 59-14, next page. The Turnpike Tussle the following week was the most frustrating coin flip the season could produce: 19-20 with three missed field goals walking the win out of Welch. This one was decided by two plays. Three different shapes of loss, one total: 8-0 to 8-3, and the regular season is over.
What people are saying
The athletics department's own writeup calls it what it was: a comeback that came up short. The ESU Bulletin framed it as the Hornets falling in the finale. On the other sideline, Hays Post called it a Senior Day win over the No. 21 Hornets. The tape agrees with all three.
Three days later the league handed out its hardware. Landon Boss was a unanimous All-MIAA first-team pick, joined on the first team by Carlos Strong Jr. on the defensive line, Clem McCullough at defensive back and Trevion Mitchell on the offensive line. Sixteen Hornets total made an All-MIAA team. MIAA fans on d2football were already deep in playoff talk by Monday, with the Northwest Missouri-Harding first-round meeting dominating those boards; one poster called the winner the likely national finalist. Whether the Hornets land in that bracket or not, the conversation up there has moved on to who's left.
Our take
Here's our read: this isn't a defense that collapsed, and it isn't an offense that quit. It's a team that gave up two explosive plays it had no business giving up, and an offense that couldn't finish three trips it had to finish. Three times inside the Fort Hays 10 on Saturday, three different endings, a turnover on downs, a field goal and an end-zone pick. In a 22-17 game, any one of those goes the other way and we're writing something else.
You outgain a team by 90 yards and lose. That's the whole scouting report.
Hot take: the three-game slide isn't a referendum on the program, it's the schedule and the margins. Northwest Missouri was always going to be a problem. The Washburn loss was the most painful kind of coin flip. This one was decided by the two longest plays on the field. Nothing about that line-up is "ESU is broken." It is, however, a loud notice that the margin for error got a lot thinner than an 8-0 start suggested, and that the defense now has 101 points against it in three weeks against conference teams that know the Hornets inside out.
The honors list isn't a consolation prize, it's an accurate read of the defense ESU mostly fielded this fall. Boss as a unanimous first-teamer is big. Strong, McCullough, Mitchell on the first team is the shape of a good football team. The job between now and whenever the next kickoff comes is making sure that team shows up for four full quarters, not three.
Next up
No game is scheduled. The Hornets close the regular season 8-3, 310 points for and 267 against, and wait on a Super Region 4 selection. The super region takes eight teams, four automatic bids from the conferences and four at-large. Three straight losses to close a season puts the committee in an interesting spot, and we're not predicting what's on their card.
Our marker for whatever comes next: if the Hornets line up for a 12th game, the stat that decides it is explosive-play defense. You don't surrender a 71-yard touchdown pass and a 67-yard touchdown run in the same game by accident, and you don't repeat that against a bracketed team and go home with a win.
Clean up the chunk plays, extend the season. Don't, and this one ends on Sunday. Either way, we'll be here with a post about it. If you'd rather back your read than just shout it, that's the point of the picks tab.